Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Daniel Kyne's avatar

Excellent summary and commentary, Sam! Particularly enjoyed seeing you include the recommendation that Ireland should aim to be more of a policy sandbox and be more experimental in our approach to problem solving through policy. Wish this was spoken more about, as Ireland is so well positioned to excel at this and will need to look at new ways to strengthen its global position as remote working threatens our FDI-tech base throughout the rest of this decade.

Expand full comment
Garret Holler's avatar

Good piece. It's funny that the hatred for Haughey that persists, like that for Dev, is much more folky shared belief than any specific grievance (not that there aren't many grievances).

Just worth considering, for future posts, and this is definitely the complaint of a local; I think you overstate how unique/unusual Ireland is, politically. I understand it's difficult to write for a foreign audience, when there's little prior knowledge of the subjects at hand, but certain statements here ('I can’t overstate just how parochial politics in Ireland can be', and 'I cannot stress to you how un-professionalised the Irish political class is' in particular) carry, for me, the familiar echoes of Irish liberals apologising for their backwards compatriots.

Plenty of Irish politics is not actually that special; having the nationalists on the Left, for instance (although many in FF would take serious umbrage at the suggestion that they were not nationalists) is not particularly unique in other states with a revolutionary foundation and a colonial past - look at Ba'athists, or Arab Nationalists of Nasser's ilk. You can find FG analogues all throughout Europe (historically the CDU, for instance, at least that's a comparison I imagine Garrett FitzGerald would have sought), and early FF in a variety of religious-populist groups.

Apologies if it sounds like I'm nitpicking - it's great to have someone in this space writing seriously about Irish politics. I've subscribed, and look forward to future output.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts